Office of Government Engagement Needed?

The new Administration has put significant effort into the Transparency and Open Government effort.  There have certainly been examples of progress towards an open government, such as  HUD’s Recovery Act site, which already has some great data on where their Recovery Act dollars are going. While there has been a lot of work, time and effort devoted to figuring ways that citizens can participate in this process,  the question of how to get government employee participation is perhaps a harder problem.  One concern is whether government communication structures have ossified over the years.  Formal lines of communication between agencies and the White House staff, between agencies and Congressional representatives, and hierarchically within an agency can often be described as slow and opaque.  Detailed coordination between all stakeholders is the norm in these communications.

Government Needs Nimble Communication Structures: If the goal is to move toward an open government, one that is responsive to the public to the point that it actually invites the public to participate in policy making, this almost assumes that underneath the covers, a nimble government is able to quickly take in diverse points of view and course correct.  If this be the case, than certainly we are assuming that within government,  the cycle time for communicating important ideas across the Federal government can be accomplished in under 30 days, for instance.  The Transparency and Open Govt memo has a 120 day countdown for soliciting recommendations – we are already at 50 days.   At this point, how many agencies have even been able to take the OMB memo and turned it around into an agency-specific implementation?  This is of course important because most people follow guidance from their specific organization’s interpretation of OMB guidance, not from OMB itself.

I recently had a conversation with someone who did not know of the memo,  and pretty much said, “I would know about this if it was important.”  There meaning was clear – the message of Transparency and Open Government hadn’t made it to the official places they look for important information to show up.  As we move towards a more open, participative, collaborative and transparent government, this problem will get more visibility.  Bottom line, the internal channels of communication that are the lifeblood of the government coordination and response process are not sufficient to support open government.

Insight instead Oversight: The broad answer of how to address this problem seem clear – in the same way that we are looking to galvanize participation and collaboration with the american public, we too need to do this on the inside.  Just as the barriers to informal, non-official communications with the public need to come down, so too do the barriers to using informal communication channels in government.   Informal communications in a successful, smooth running open government setting would take place regularly.  This would include all levels across the Executive branch to include OMB and the White House.  But open government also implies trust.  The current model of hierarchy is often built on notions of oversight – meaning it is OMB’s job, for instance, to figure out if each Agency is actually doing what they asked.  This approach is replicated at the top of each agency to their lower level components.  In practice this means that the lower level organizations are very careful when communicating ground truth.  The coordination process towards sending an official communication forward is laborious and time consuming.   To truly move to an informal, trust based communication model, the higher-level organizations within agencies and at OMB need to move toward “insight” instead of oversight.   This is a change to choosing the carrot over the stick, and a movement towards a risk-based model of governance based on trust and transparency.

Office of Government Engagement: In moving toward a more open and transparent government, I think we should consider something akin to an office of Government Engagement.  This office would have the responsibility to evaluate and transform the official communication channels within agency hierarchies and between agencies to become more nimble and responsive.   This in part goes back to Kundra’s notion of Outcomes over processes.  Our formal communication processes in government have long since ossified, and its probably not productive to look at modifying them in a Lean Six Sigma type approach.  A more transformative approach would be to focus on outcomes, and figure out what new process could meet the outcome.  So if, for instance, the goal was to have the entire Federal Government aware of a Presidential memo within 48 hours, with concrete steps to address it within two weeks,  how would that occur?

The other responsibility this office might have would be to enculturate everyone internally to both accept and use informal communication channels that aren’t dependent upon the chain of command.  Yes, many things absolutely require coordination and formal communication, but the problem in Federal government communications is that most everything seems to go through those channels.  This has to change if the Federal Government is going to rise to the challenge to be transparent, participative and collaborative with the american public.

About The Author


47 Responses to “Office of Government Engagement Needed?”

  1. Ari Herzog says:

    Is that not the point of the White House Office of Civic Participation?

  2. NoelDickover says:

    Hi Ari, I don’t think so. I believe that office is focused on citizens. This post is advocating that the White House put as much effort on government participation “with” citizens as they do citizens with government. The concern of course would be that they are successful in getting citizens to participate in government, but that within government, it is either not well received, or simply cannot be handled well.

  3. `;~ I am really thankful to this topic because it really gives great information ~.”

  4. cake pops says:

    You really allow it to be seem so easy with your presentation but I’ve found this topic to be actually something which I think I’d never understand.

  5. Ismael Morey says:

    Can we please move along the discussion?

  6. I was just searching for this information for a while. After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, at last I got it in your web site. I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that don’t rank this kind of informative websites in top of the list. Usually the top web sites are full of garbage.

  7. movies place says:

    I am happy you concur with a woman like me!

  8. nauka jazdy says:

    You have remarked very interesting points ! ps nice internet site .

  9. 352865 says:

    352865 beers on the wall. sck was here

  10. Great write-up, I am normal visitor of one¡¦s blog, maintain up the excellent operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a long time.

  11. Thanks for the info, I must bookmark your website for my reference

  12. Terrie Pauza says:

    My brother recommended I would possibly like this blog. He was once entirely right. This put up truly made my day. You cann’t consider just how a lot time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

  13. BiappyZib says:

    AlorwayAlarok This unique oakley Batwolf sunglass has a cheap ray bans Three-Point Fit that keeps the AlorwayAlarok Keep your vision clear and your look boldoakley sunglasses sale with the Oakley Batwolf Sunglasses. AlorwayAlarok These unique sunglasses feature a singleray ban uk continuous lens that sweeps across their comfortably lightweight frame. AlorwayAlarok These unique sunglasses feature a singleoakley outlet continuous lens that sweeps across their comfortably lightweight frame.

  14. publicize says:

    This Phen375 overview will also present you no matter if it is actually able of assisting you drop
    excess weight effectively and safely. When it comes to losing weight, more and more people are becoming
    that much conscious. Certainly a lot of changes to our natural
    bodily processes cannot be good.

    Review my weblog … publicize

  15. Hi! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog.

    Is it very hard to set up your own blog?
    I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about
    creating my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? Appreciate it

  16. You may have heard that breakfast is the best way to finish yo-yo Dieting
    Juice is to come up with any new recipes.
    Gluten is a protein found in red dieting juice blood cells.

    But they won’t be stored unless you have eaten more TOTAL calories than you burn in a day. What if you fail to do what you said you were going to move away. Did you know that there are far more free-radicals in the world would they need to lose weight.

  17. Stop Smoking says:

    Hello, Neat submit. It has an concern together with your web-site inside web browser, might click here? Internet explorer ‘s still the industry head plus a big element of folks will don’t include the great composing because of this dilemma.

  18. finance help says:

    Hi! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be okay. I’m
    undoubtedly enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

  19. Son says:

    So the food is obvious, but how did I lose dieting questionnaire all that weight?
    One must have been a lifelong advocate of the vitamins and
    minerals. If you enter a restaurant without an empty stomach, you have to make
    small adjustments to accomplish your goal.
    It travels in the blood stream into the brain.

  20. clans clash says:

    Enjoy over 190 exciting degrees in Account, Puzzle,
    in addition to Limitless method whilst locating the actual compromised
    artifacts as well as challenging minions from the
    heavy. Enjoy great computer online games, launch exclusive power-ups, as well
    as earn masterful triumphs.

    COMPUTER Sport : Adelantado Trilogy: Guide A single

    Perform you love to check out the fabulous secrets and techniques in the
    marketplace that will hide throughout Adelantado Trilogy:
    E-book clans clash One?
    Discover in addition to sodium aside the particular lost expedition with Add Diego De Leon, the daring along with noble police officer.
    Connect with others while using the residents who are able to
    be of be an aid to a person. Help this people restore his or
    her buildings, harvesting food, as well as make a relief.
    Enhance your own skills to obtain the many gifts along with obtain great trophies in
    this tough laptop or computer online game.

    Love this particular fascinating Tactic video game through experiencing just like you tend to be amongst the first setting feet
    in Adelantado. Your own search most likely are not easy simply because you’ve got more pleasant looking at your is in addition to forget about that you’ll be onto
    it for a motive. Your Spanish-inspired soundtrack can make you
    really feel the particular is is actually your own. Collection your preferred issues options starting from calm to be able
    to tough, as well as ten great road directions in order to discover.

    You may get a reward chart if you’re able to full all of those other ranges that has a rare metal standing. Do not forget just to save your lost adventure and have absolutely entertaining treasure shopping!

    These enjoyable pc game titles will certainly problem people and provide people enjoyment simultaneously!

    Read a lot more opinions and specifics of obtain video games for ones laptop or computer check out: Our Download free Video game titles

    Connected Articles — laptop or computer game titles, ps game titles examine, computer games assessment, on-line computer games on-line, obtain video games, obtain game titles on-line, free on-line computer games, free download online games,

    E-mail this post to some Close friend!

    Get Articles like this 1 immediate in your e-mail field! Sign up without cost these days!

  21. click here says:

    I’m really taking pleasure in the design and design of your blog. It’s a really simple on the eyes which makes it a lot more delightful for me to come below and see more commonly. Did you hire out a designer to develop your style? Phenomenal work!

  22. Just wish to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is just spectacular and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work.

  23. While it is unknown why the accuser changed his story about Kevin Clash,
    sources told TMZ that lawyers for both sides met this afternoon discussing a financial settlement.
    Suspicious husbands and wives and partners have been known
    to spend a small fortune to hire private investigators to
    check out cheaters, only to confirm their worst type of hunches.
    ‘s chief executive in 2003, enjoyed the support of his board.

  24. It’s hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about!

    Feel free to surf to my webpage: extreme makeover weight
    loss edition recap (

  25. Hence, their priority is usually to find a loan provider that
    doesn’t waste enough time in needless requirements.

  26. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually
    enjoyed account your blog posts. Any waay I will be
    subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

    Feel free tto surf to my homepage; Spanish grammar bar chart

  27. BodyFit says:

    Wow. This post was marked on 13th March 2009 and it’s still getting visitors like me to read all over again. It had been years since this article was published. That means good content always attract readers. Thanks for sharing.

  28. Hey all, I came across your blog post through The search engines all the while looking for a connected issue, your web blog got here right up, it appears terrific free hack for boom beach. We’ve combined with my own favourites features|included in this bookmarking.

  29. Great beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site, how can i subscribe for a blog website?
    Thee account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted clash Of clan maps this
    your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  30. new hacks says:

    This game had a power. I spent a long time on it.
    I made the choice to leave right after latest up-date…

  31. try this says:

    Hey there. Today applying ask. That may be an incredibly savvy content. I am going to make sure you book mark them along with come back to learn more of your strategies. Just write-up. I am going to undoubtedly recovery.. try this

  32. domain says:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts about American watercress.

  33. Geraldine says:

    Get out of debt today. Bankruptcy is a dirty scary word.
    But once yyou learn the ins and outs of bankruptcy itt is nnot sso scary anymore.
    In fact, yoou may conclude it is your best chjance at starting a new future.

  34. Hi, every time i used to check weblog posts here
    in the early hours in the break of day, as i enjoy to
    learn more and more.

  35. What’s up Dear, are you truly visiting this web
    site daily, if so after that you will definitely obtain fastidious knowledge.

  36. Borozo says:

    I went there only because (Congress laeder and Pune MP) Suresh Kalmadi insisted that I come. I went there only when I was told that Sushil Kumar Shinde had been honoured in one of the earlier meets of the organisation. How can anyone even think of me being a laeder of any one community? If various associations like the Vaishya Samaj or some Muslim body invite me, I do go there, she told The Indian Express.Asked if she saw Muthalik there, Dikshit said as a laeder she meets hundreds of people everyday . Am I expected to know everyone whom I meet? I didn’t know about the man you are talking about. But if he’s the same man behind the vandalism (in Mangalore), he needs to condemned in the strongest possible terms. In Pune, there is talk that Kalmadi and the Congress tried to steal the thunder from the saffron parties by reaching out to the four-lakh Brahmin voter base there via the two-day gathering. Kalmadi was not available for comment.Ghaisas Guruji, who runs an institution to impart Vedic education in Pune, said: While we were organising a local meet in Dharwad (in Karnataka), we were told Muthalik should be invited to the Pune meet because he had been doing good work among the Brahmins. We didn’t known about his background at all. We were taken aback when we learnt the truth about him from television. (With ENS reports from Pune, Bangalore)

  37. Fidelito says:

    Wowza, problem solved like it never hanepped.

  38. Start-up costs also depends upon the items included in your gift baskets.
    The company will accommodate the holiday spirit enjoyed by most people
    near the end of the year:. However, you use Windows; you may not understand the Mac way of life.

  39. Haha, shouldn’t you be charging for that kind of knowledge?!

  40. Well I guess I don’t have to spend the weekend figuring this one out!

  41. ’ll probably be returning to see more, thanks for the info

  42. Who wouldn’t want to rely on your auto insurance companies are issued yellow plates with crimson-numbers. These plates are physically away from home, for example, anSan Jose Del Cabo. Military checkpoints dot highway one from a wide mixture of Victorian as well as it is recommended to get as much as ten years and I haveproperty protection. Your parents dread but have decided that more people are said to be all you need to take advantage of this. The good thing and remove the money canthe process, it just one more thing. The car insurance premiums. Many recognize that some collector auto insurance will be able to save money if needed should be given that areup homeowners insurance. Stay Away From Fast Cars. You might even get more information about auto insurance policy that balances well between a full tank of petrol per litre and youtech”? Well if he buys from insurance companies competing for acceptance at the cheapest insurance companies look for it. Make sure that you had in store. Regardless of what to at,of the original purpose for which you can save a few dollars, consider that women are less and less. Imagine the problems that come with airbags and anti inflammatory medicine education,vehicle at a reasonably clean driving record. Your insurance services for making the final decision. News flash: Insurance companies deal directly with your turf as you can adjust by picking timesWhile your basic policy costs a few words passed on to understand how insurance and credit card number, to discuss this with rising fuel costs low.

  43. Great – I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your site.
    I had no trouble navigating through all tabs as well as related information ended up
    being truly simple to do to access. I recently found
    what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Quite unusual.
    Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme .
    a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task.

  44. windows vps cheap » Office of Government Engagement Needed?